The Luigi Mangione case has been such a hard improvement. The general public response has been tough to look at. I hate the American healthcare system. It’s rigged in opposition to us and places revenue above human life. Enterprise practices like which might be legal and wish to vary. Insurance coverage corporations should be taught that persons are not a commodity. Nevertheless, preventing greed and cynicism with deadly violence doesn’t remedy something. Furthermore, making a people hero out of the troubled soul who murdered United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson is certain to encourage extra misguided acts of violence. The Investigation Discovery true crime documentary Who Is Luigi Mangione? (on Max) takes a take a look at Mangione’s case and tries to make sense of the aftermath. However is it important viewing? Not essentially.
This doc breaks some new floor, however not a lot.
This Investigation Discovery unique documentary accommodates a number of particulars I wasn’t conscious of. Nevertheless, lots of the reporting is repetitive. The 20/20 particular Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Homicide (Hulu) already coated many of the floor explored on this documentary. With a case like this, it’s essential that protection brings one thing new to the desk and exists as greater than a cynical rehash of the recognized information. I say that as a result of when the media spends hours on finish overlaying instances like this, it offers deeply disturbed folks another reason to decide on violence. When lonely, remoted people predisposed to acts of aggression see Mangione go from no person to world-famous in a single day, which may encourage one other vigilante to attempt to make a reputation for themselves.
Who Is Luigi Mangione? gives cynical protection of a case we’re all acquainted with.
The reporting comes throughout as cynical for quite a few causes. Living proof: It looks like the filmmakers had been determined to get anybody with even a tangential connection to the accused on digicam so they may rush the footage into postproduction and get it on air. We solely hear from a few individuals who knew Mangione on any degree. Amongst them are his yoga teacher and a neighbor. I believe the reporting could be extra significant if we heard from folks with a deeper connection to the accused. On the very least, the reporting would learn as much less jaded.
The filmmakers behind the documentary additional reveal their cynicism by dropping sight of United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson within the reporting. He serves as little greater than a footnote on this psychological profile of his killer.
No matter Thompson’s totally reprehensible actions as a CEO and his well-documented shortcomings on a humanitarian degree, he’s nonetheless a key element on this case. Successfully writing him out of his personal story comes throughout as callous and cynical. On the finish of this system, correspondent Dan Abrams laments how Brian Thompson has been forgotten in all of this. Nevertheless, the staff behind this doc largely fed into that very pattern and seemingly didn’t see the irony.
All issues thought of, you’ll be able to take a cross on this ID unique documentary. When you’re on the lookout for protection that may deepen your understanding of the case and do justice to the sufferer, look elsewhere.
Abstract
‘Who Is Luigi Mangione?’ prioritizes sensational protection over paying tribute to the sufferer.
Categorized:Evaluations
